Hodges same-sex couples. Supreme Court legalized gay marriage. The state says the decision legalizing same-sex marriage in all 50 states doesn't change that, though the Roes argue birth certificates are among the rights of marriage mentioned in the high court ruling. Justice Sonia Sotomayor, who handles emergency appeals from Utah and the five other states in the 10th Circuit, turned the matter over to the entire court.
Utah officials told the couple that one mother must adopt the baby as a step-parent, a process the Roes say is costly, invasive and unfair. District Judge Dee Benson said the assisted reproduction case wasn't hard to decide. Share story. Many states have similar laws governing artificial insemination that previously had not applied to same-sex unions because the rules were specific to married couples, said NeJamie, a professor at the University of California, Los Angeles.
Recommended on Chicago Tribune. The Utah case could have an effect on other pending cases, though the parental rights of same-sex couples will same sex marriage states requirements in West Jordan on what state laws are already on the books for heterosexual couples, he said.
Supreme Court legalized gay marriage. Benson essentially dismissed same sex marriage states requirements in West Jordan rationale, asking Parker repeatedly to explain why the rules for the Roes should differ than those for similarly-situated married men.
District Judge Dee Benson said the case wasn't hard to decide in the wake of the U. Veterans Fertility Bill Withdrawn August 13, A federal judge has ordered the state of Utah to list the names of the lesbian couple on a birth certificate as the mothers of their new baby.
State attorneys countered that Utah law declares a husband is automatically the father in cases of assisted reproduction but that doesn't extend to same-sex unions. In June, the justices decided not to weigh in on the constitutionality of defining marriage as being between a man and woman.
Related posts. The Utah case could have an effect on other pending cases, though the parental rights of same-sex couples will depend on what state laws are already on the books for heterosexual couples, he said. Under Utah laws governing assisted reproduction, only a married husband whose wife conceives with donated sperm is automatically considered the child's father.
District Judge Dee Benson. Still, the couple was still surprised by his pronouncement, although no judge's ruling changes their commitment to their daughter, Angie Roe said. And the judge was absolutely right.